
The German film At Ellen’s Age, directed by Pia Marais, chronicles the journey of a German flight attendant who leaves her cheating boyfriend, loses her job and joins a group of radical animal rights activists. Ellen deliberately destroys the foundations of her life and opens her arms to whatever comes next, good or bad. The main storyline–of Ellen trying to find herself–is paralleled by the fate of the animals the activists rescue; they too are lost when released into the wild to fend for themselves and, as with Ellen, it’s unclear whether or not they will make it.
I appreciated the discussion of veganism, factory farming and animal testing–all were dealt with quite soberly. There are activists with different points of view about direct action and the kinds of action that are beneficial or detrimental to the cause, which I found to be an honest portrayal of the issues facing activists today.
I did have a few qualms though:
The activists are your stereotypical dirty hippies, who live together in a dirty commune. The film made activists out to be a certain “type,” one-dimensional, and reinforces negative stereotypes rather than exploring the fact vegans and animal rights activists come from all walks of life.
My biggest problem with the film, though, is Ellen’s near catatonic passivity. It makes sense at the start of the film where she’s trapped in a meaningless existence, but she never seems to change or grow as a character, which made the story somewhat anti-climactic. Even after she joins the activists in order to “find herself,” at no point does she ever exhibit any real sympathy towards animals. She tells the activists how much she admires their idealism, but doesn’t become idealistic herself or really cares about anything other than herself throughout the whole film.
One scene that really bothered me was when the activists break into a laboratory to trash the place and release all of the the lab mice. Ellen doesn’t participate in the break-in, and when she sees that the getaway van has crashed, and that mice are all over the road getting hit by cars, she does nothing to help them, she simply looks at them and walks away. Perhaps this where art and logic clash, because seeing all those white mice on the black road at night was a striking cinematic shot, but it did nothing to help me understand Ellen’s character, on the contrary, I was more confused than ever about who this woman was.
Because of Ellen’s apathy, I thought she would come to realize that activism isn’t for her and move onto something else, but in the end she goes to Africa to help another group of activists stop Sudanese poachers! And she is just as unsure about her position on animal rights at the end of the film as she was at the start, but is still so desperate to find an identity for herself, she’ll try almost anything.
Had Ellen been a more compelling central character, with a marked change in her beliefs and demeanor as the film progressed, I might have felt differently about At Ellen’s Age. Simply put, the protagonist is a middle-aged woman who does nothing but feel sorry for herself. The animals in this film are truly fighting for their lives–watching Ellen fight to bring meaning to hers, pales in comparison.